Save Our Sidmouth

How ‘no confidence vote’ came to be rejected by Council let down by its Leader

2 Comments

A letter, copied below, from today’s Sidmouth Herald (22/09/17), explains:

                                  Disbelief at ‘no confidence vote’

 (photo: Extra Ordinary Meeting at Knowle,13/09/2017)

Sir
The issue of no confidence in EDDC Leader Paul Diviani is nothing new, as the 4,000 people who took part in the SOS Mass March to Knowle, nearly 5 years ago, would agree. (Nov 3rd, 2012, photos archived on http://www.saveoursidmouth.com). How is it, then, that the ‘Motion against East Devon District Council leader’ failed’ (Sidmouth Herald, 15/09/17)?

Paul Diviani had, according to a senior Conservative colleague, clearly broken trust with the District Council. At the County Health Scrutiny Committee, the EDDC Leader had failed to represent his own Council’s unanimous (i.e. cross-party) recommendation that hospital bedcuts should stop until an effective alternative had been shown to be in place. His contrary vote had influenced the outcome at the DCC, the only body capable of statutory action, thereby apparently betraying not just his own Council, but the people of East Devon that they represent. This left the Tory group of District Councillors “caught between a rock and a hard place”, as Cathy Gardner (EDDC Ward Member Sidmouth Town, East Devon Alliance) reminded them, at the Extra Ordinary Meeting at Knowle (13/09/17).

But all the Tory Councillors present (just one abstained), did an extraordinary thing. To the disbelief of the public crammed into the Council Chamber, they turned the debate away from their uncomfortable Leader’s conduct, and onto problems with the National Health Service. Then, in voting against the Motion of No Confidence in the Leader, they effectively blockvoted against their own unanimous recommendation regarding NHS problems and bedcuts, taken just a few weeks’ earlier. The sort of thing, and Leader, that brings a Council into disrepute?

Jacqueline Green
Sidmouth

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “How ‘no confidence vote’ came to be rejected by Council let down by its Leader

  1. Pingback: EDDC Tory councillors voted against themselves to protect Leader | East Devon Watch

  2. Democracy is well and truly dead!!!

    Democracy can be measured, in part at least, by how well elected and unelected officials can be held to account by the public. Unless you can hold officials to account, then you cannot hold them to account for their openness with facts – without accountability there can be no transparency either.

    EDDC has been beset with both transparency and accountability issues for years. The CCG’s consultation has also been lambasted for a lack of transparency (e.g. on clinical evidence supporting their proposals) and accountability.

    This block vote by Conservatives supporting Diviani in contradiction to their own previous vote is yet another nail in the coffin of democracy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s