Save Our Sidmouth


Leave a comment

Another question to the TAFF on East Devon Business Forum

This is the one put by Barry Curwen, of Sidmouth Chamber of Commerce,  to the Task and Finish Forum: Business, on 12 March 2013. It is reproduced with his permission:

In a representation to the East Devon MP, the Rt Hon Hugo Swire, on 22 June 2012, I provided detailed evidence of serious transgressions in the East Devon Local Plan process.  As a result I asked him to undertake an inquiry which should include the relationship and influence of the East Devon Business Forum as there does not appear to be sufficient separation for their influence to be appropriate or legitimate.
As part of the MP’s action he wrote to Mark Williams, Chief Executive of EDDC on the 14 August and received a reply dated 19 September.
I will quote from Mr William’s letter, “I am aware that the relationship of the Council with EDBF has become a source of concern to some.  That being said, many might comment that the issue is perhaps being articulated more as a result of local political differences of opinion rather than anything of notable substance.
Also “As regards the suggestion that the EDBF perhaps exercises undue influence in relation to planning matters, I can find no evidence to substantiate this”.
Given the EDBF boast and self congratulation in their minutes that they had significantly influenced the planning policy in the emerging Local Plan and the numerous examples provided in the report compiled by resident Tony Green and sent to Mr Williams, I believe our MP has been seriously misled by the Chief Executive’s comments.
With regard to the statements revealed by the investigation of the Daily Telegraph made by Cllr Graham Brown, who is of course chairman of the EDBF, the response from EDDC was entirely predictable; “We are not aware of Cllr Brown having any improper influence on the planning process”.
Given the Chief Executives questionable legal advice that this council cannot investigate matters relating to planning, not just planning decisions but all matters including planning process, this makes this statement farcical.
An independent Public Inquiry, set up to examine all aspects of the planning process employed by EDDC is necessary and if there is any hint of corruption, the police should also be involved to undertake a criminal investigation.
Public fears and concerns will not be satisfied by any internal EDDC investigation.  The honesty and integrity of your planning system is in serious doubt.  You are in danger of losing the public trust completely.
In view of the constraints placed on this Forum following the legal advice of the Chief Executive, can this Forum support the call for a Full Independent Public Inquiry to examine all aspects of the planning process employed by EDDC including the role and influence of the EDBF?


Leave a comment

The Future of the East Devon Business Forum now in question

The repercussions from the Graham Brown affair are many (see recent posts on this SOS website).  One is the question of what will happen to the East Devon Business Forum, from which he has now resigned. The reaction from its current Vice-Chair can be viewed at http://sidmouthindependentnews.wordpress.com , 16 March Letter to members of EDBF from Roy Stuart .

A window on the workings of EDBF has been opened by the setting  up of a special group (TAFF), by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. TAFF Chairman Graham Troman and his team have been asked to examine how the Business Forum works as  a ‘joint body’ (as the Council CEO describes it) with Councillors. Despite this TAFF having been hampered (some say,’muzzled’) , as extensively reported on our website and on the SIN blog, questions can now be publicly aired.  We hope they will all be addressed.

As promised, SOS will post examples of these questions. This one was from Marianne Rixson of Sidford W.I.,  to the Task and Finish Forum: Business, on 12 March 2013:

An article in the Sidmouth Herald, in June 2012, had the heading “Local Plan Chief: I was misled over jobs hub. No idea why it was included”. The Local Plan Chief in question was  Cllr Mike Allen, who had chaired the Local Development Framework Panel.In this article, he publicly expressed his astonishment when  ( after public consultation had ended),  the 5 hectares of employment land site at Sidford Fields had somehow appeared in the Local Plan. Cllr Allen told the Herald reporter, “I have no idea why the Sidford-Sidbury proposal was included but it was represented to me as a result of consultations with Sidmouth Town Council, which it clearly was not.
“I am investigating this and will find out. Once I find the facts I will almost certainly be asking the scrutiny committee to look at this.”
In light of the Cllr Brown revelations, with the damning connections to the East Devon Business Forum and his planning consultancy, surely the Sidford proposal must form part of this TAFF enquiry?


Leave a comment

BBC ONE, The Politics Show: Interviews with East Devon Councillors, possibly broadcast 11h00 today, Sun 17th March

Independent Councillors Roger Giles and Claire Wright will be commenting on the present controversies in East Devon. They will discuss the  impact of the National Planning Policy Framework deadline (scheduled for Wednesday 27th March), dubbed Black Wednesday for the Countryside.

More at http://www.claire-wright.org

Large crowds are expected at the Countdown to Black Wednesday protest march next Saturday (23/03) , at Feniton , a village under threat from developers.  Graham Brown, the disgraced ex-Chair of the East Devon Business Forum, was formerly the Councillor for Feniton and Buckerell.  PROTEST MARCH

More information on yesterday’s post on this SOS website. Also at the SIN blog,  http://sidmouthindependentnews.wordpress.com